All the reasons Emmerdale’s Gabby and Vinny will never work

Emmerdale’s Gabby and Vinny are the soap’s newest couple, with the pair having finally confessed their feelings for one another. Gabby and Vinny have been back and forth a lot, as nothing is ever straightforward in the Dales.

While they appear to be love’s young dream, it looks unlikely that Gabby and Vinny’s relationship could stand the test of time. But, you never know – it is Emmerdale, after all.

Here, we take a look at the reasons why we think Gabby and Vinny’s romance won’t work in Emmerdale.

Vinny and Gabby kiss — Vinny and Gabby have fallen for one another (Credit: ITV)

Gabby and Vinny’s differences

It’s no secret that Gabby and Vinny are very different characters. Gabby is no stranger to drama and trouble, while Vinny is much more reserved – despite being a Dingle. Gabby even admitted she just wanted to have ‘fun’ with Vinny, while he was noticeably developing feelings.

Actress Rosie Bentham, who plays Gabby, has even expressed her surprise over Gabby and Vinny being romantically matched together.

“It’s a bit of a chalk and cheese situation, isn’t it? When the story got pitched to me, I was like: ‘Oh, how is that going to happen?’ But as the story goes on, the writing has been quite funny and light-hearted,” she admitted to Digital Spy.

But, they do say opposites attract.

Relationships

Historically, Gabby has always gone for bad boys. Remember her toxic affair with Jamie Tate – who she shares son Thomas with – and engagement to lying rogue Nicky Miligan? However, maybe a good guy is exactly what Gabby needs!

Vinny’s only former partner is his late wife, Liv Flaherty. She died in 2022 when a catastrophic storm hit the village, leaving him devastated. Liv was also asexual, therefore she and Vinny never had sex, meaning he was still a virgin when he got to know Gabby.

Losing his virginity was a big deal to Vinny, especially with Gabby being far more experienced than him. But, they got over any hurdles and managed to seal the deal – much to Vinny’s excitement.

Vinny and Liv — Vinny’s ex Liv is pals with Gabby (Credit: ITV)

Liv and Gabby’s friendship

Gabby was close friends with Vinny’s wife Liv, who sadly died in 2022. The pair formed a close bond and even lived together at one point.

It may seem odd that Gabby’s now started a relationship with her friend’s widower, given how close she and Liv were. Or, odd for Vinny to get together with one of his late wife’s close friends.

However, the couple appear to have accepted this. Liv’s brother Aaron gave Vinny his blessing when he heard about his new romance. Also, Vinny has insisted he feels Liv would be happy for him and Gabby. But, is this situation all just a little to uncomfortable?

Belle smiles in Emmerdale (Credit: ITV) — Is Belle better suited to Vinny? (Credit: ITV)

Vinny and Belle?

With Vinny and Gabby being very opposite, it’s likely they could find a better match in the village. For a while, it seemed like Vinny may get together with Belle Dingle, with the pair growing close.

He’s been a huge support to Belle, who has been at the centre of a domestic abuse storyline with her husband Tom King. Emmerdale fans have even predicted that Vinny will be the one to find out Belle is being abused.

Is love on the cards for Vinny and Belle? We reckon they could be a better suited couple!

Emmerdale fans have their say

Fans of Emmerdale have been keen to share their opinions on the soap’s latest couple. Unsurprisingly, many fans aren’t convinced that things will work out between Vinny and Gabby.

“Sorry but I can’t see Gabby and Vinny together,” one Emmerdale viewer wrote on X. Another said: “Gabby is just using Vinny. How long before he realises?”

A third fan said: “Vinny and Gabby? That would never happen in real life,” while a final viewer said: “Gabby & Vinny just aren’t a good match.”